Sandiganbayan rejects Revilla’s 2nd motion to inhibit presiding justice
MANILA, Philippines — The Sandiganbayan Third Division has denied the Second Motion for Inhibition filed by former Sen. Bong Revilla, which sought the voluntary recusal of the division's chairperson.
In a resolution dated September 24, the anti-graft court found Revilla’s motion to be without merit, ruling that Associate Justice Karl Miranda must proceed with his judicial duty to sit and hear the case.
In rejecting Revilla’s motion, the anti-graft court reiterated that there is no ground for mandatory inhibition under Section 11, Canon III of the 2025 Code of Judicial Conduct and Accountability, which does not include a judge's relationship with the counsel of a party's witness.
While judges may voluntarily inhibit themselves for just and valid reasons, the court found that Revilla failed to present the clear and convincing evidence of arbitrariness required to prove bias or partiality.
“There must be clear and convincing evidence of acts or conduct clearly indicative of arbitrariness. In this regard, the court found that Revilla failed to demonstrate any arbitrary act or conduct that would warrant the recusal of Justice Miranda from participating in this case,” the Sandiganbayan’s resolution read.
Revilla reiterated concerns regarding Miranda’s brother, Buenaventura Miranda, who serves as counsel for former Undersecretary Roberto Bernardo, a witness in his malversation case.
The former lawmaker argued that Miranda and the Chavez Miranda Aseoche Law Offices (CMA Law) assisted Bernardo during the preliminary investigation, during his appearances as a witness, and potentially with his application for admission to the Witness Protection Program (WPP).
Revilla also claimed that Miranda relied heavily on Bernardo's allegedly uncorroborated testimony when he issued a Concurring and Dissenting Opinion, or "Separate Opinion," voting to deny Revilla's bail application.
Furthermore, Revilla pointed to an incident in February 2026, shortly before arraignment, where Justice Miranda allegedly approached the accused in the courtroom and encouraged them to look into the benefits of the Good Conduct and Time Allowance Law. Revilla argued that these remarks gave the impression that the judge had already prejudged the case and assumed the accused would face lengthy prison sentences.
Addressing the relationship between the Miranda brothers, the court emphasized that Bernardo is merely a witness, not a party to the case, and was presented by the prosecution rather than by the lawyer Miranda.
Regarding the participation of CMA Law and the attendance of lawyer Carl Mucho at the hearings, the court noted that Miranda is not part of and has no interest in CMA Law, nor is he related to Mucho.
The court also agreed with the prosecution that the authority to retain Bernardo in the WPP rests with the Department of Justice and the Office of the Ombudsman, making Revilla's claims of bias on this front purely speculative.
The court also defended Miranda’s opinion on the bail application, noting that it was replete with citations of other witness testimonies and documentary evidence.
The anti-graft court emphasized that a dissent simply demonstrates a difference in judicial interpretation and that adverse rulings, without more, do not prove bias or partiality warranting inhibition.
With regard to the remarks on the GCTA Law, the anti-graft court ruled that these remarks were not born out of prejudice, but rather reflected Miranda’s long history as a staunch advocate for restorative justice, prison reform, and the rights of PDLs.
“The court then enumerated Justice Miranda's efforts to promote the rights and welfare of all PDLs, which included the following: (1) he has continuously coordinated with the Bureau of Corrections, Bureau of Jail Management and Penology, as well as private persons and groups regarding assistance to and the plight of PDLs; (2) he taught at the college inside the New Bilibid Prison in Muntinlupa City; (3) he assisted in setting up E-DALAW facilities in various jail and correctional facilities; (4) he helped organized national competitions, exhibitions, and an auction for artworks made by PDLs; and (6) spoke on restorative justice and prison reform on various platform, including in a podcast of the Supreme Court where he also discussed good conduct time allowance in relation to prison reform and restorative justice.”
The anti-graft court added that advising the accused to know their legal rights is consistent with the court's duty to ensure due regard for the rights of the accused and cannot be equated with declaring a conviction.
“The court emphasized that advising the accused to know their legal rights cannot reasonably be equated with declaring that he will be convicted. If anything, providing information concerning a possible statutory benefit is consistent with the court's duty to ensure due regard to the rights of the accused,” the anti-graft court said.
Revilla is being charged with malversation over the alleged anomalous P92.8-million flood control project in Pandi, Bulacan.
abtestabtest Prosecution legal spox Tolosa receives impeachment court warning over comments By Ian Laqui | 19 hours ago House prosecution legal spokesperson Benjamin Tolosa said that he also received a warning from the Senate impeachment court... Headlines SC dismisses petitions vs vote threshold in Sara Duterte impeachment trial By Ian Laqui | 12 hours ago The Supreme Court has dismissed separate petitions challenging the Senate Impeachment Court’s interpretation of the... Headlines Dizon denies cover-up in Taguig flood control probe: 'We'll go where evidence leads us' By Cristina Chi | 17 hours ago Public Works Secretary Vince Dizon has vowed "no cover-up" in his department's probe into Taguig’s flood... Headlines VP Sara spokesmen patch things up By Evelyn Macairan | 5 hours ago he misunderstanding between Vice President Sara Duterte’s spokesman Paolo Panelo and defense panel spokesman Michael... Headlines Baste: I would have blocked GenCorp deals By Daphne Galvez | 1 day ago Davao City Mayor Sebastian “Baste” Duterte faced the Senate impeachment court yesterday as a hostile witness,... Headlines Latest More in Headlines SC junks petitions vs lower impeach vote to convict PLDT wants to block violent ‘grooming’ sites Marcos Jr. institutionalizes online budget monitoring portal OP, others given 5 days to answer BSKE deferment plea abtest Digital platform launched for anti-dynasty law initiative By Mark Ernest Villeza | 5 hours ago The People’s Initiative Coalition Against Dynasty, through its Dapat Isa Lang initiative, launched a digital signature platform yesterday in its push to end political dynasties. Headlines Palace tells Velasco to face probe; houses raided By Alexis Romero | 5 hours ago Malacañang has advised former House speaker Lord Allan Velasco to come forward and shed light on the allegations... Headlines Bonoan remains accused in graft case By Daphne Galvez | 5 hours ago Former public works secretary Manuel Bonoan will remain as Sen. Jinggoy Estrada’s co-accused in a graft case linked... Headlines Fined telcos ask NTC for due process By Elijah Felice Rosales | 5 hours ago The country’s biggest telcos are asking the National Telecommunications Commission (NTC) to observe due process after... Headlines Philippines falls in innovation index By EJ Macababbad | 5 hours ago The Philippines slipped two places in the 2026 Global Innovation Index, as limited resources for innovation outweigh the country’s... Headlines Recommended Lacson dismisses Cayetano’s mockery 5 hours ago Sen. Panfilo Lacson brushed off Minority Leader Alan Peter Cayetano’s recent statements labeling him as the Senate’s... HeadlinesALAN PETER CAYETANOLACSON SC junks petitions vs lower impeach vote to convict 5 hours ago The Supreme Court has junked the three petitions challenging the ruling of the Senate impeachment court that allowed a lower... HeadlinesSARA VP Sara spokesmen patch things up 5 hours ago he misunderstanding between Vice President Sara Duterte’s spokesman Paolo Panelo and defense panel spokesman Michael... HeadlinesSARA DUTERTE SC dismisses petitions vs vote threshold in Sara Duterte impeachment trial 12 hours ago The Supreme Court has dismissed separate petitions challenging the Senate Impeachment Court’s interpretation of the... HeadlinesIMPEACHMENTSARA DUTERTESARA DUTERTE'S IMPEACHMENT Dizon denies cover-up in Taguig flood control probe: 'We'll go where evidence leads us' 17 hours ago Public Works Secretary Vince Dizon has vowed "no cover-up" in his department's probe into Taguig’s flood... HeadlinesDIZONDPWHTAGUIG next Recommended Lacson dismisses Cayetano’s mockery Sen. Panfilo Lacson brushed off Minority Leader Alan Peter Cayetano’s recent statements labeling him as the Senate’s “chief justice” and “prosecutor,” saying he would have taken the titles as a compliment if they came from a credible source. 5 hours ago ALAN PETER CAYETANO LACSON SC junks petitions vs lower impeach vote to convict The Supreme Court has junked the three petitions challenging the ruling of the Senate impeachment court that allowed a lower number of votes to convict Vice President Sara Duterte. 5 hours ago SARA VP Sara spokesmen patch things up he misunderstanding between Vice President Sara Duterte’s spokesman Paolo Panelo and defense panel spokesman Michael Poa has been resolved. 5 hours ago SARA DUTERTE SC dismisses petitions vs vote threshold in Sara Duterte impeachment trial The Supreme Court has dismissed separate petitions challenging the Senate Impeachment Court’s interpretation of the two-thirds vote requirement needed to convict Vice President Sara Duterte. 12 hours ago IMPEACHMENT SARA DUTERTE SARA DUTERTE'S IMPEACHMENT Dizon denies cover-up in Taguig flood control probe: 'We'll go where evidence leads us' Public Works Secretary Vince Dizon has vowed "no cover-up" in his department's probe into Taguig’s flood control works, an attempt to clear the air after his answer at a Senate hearing was construed as a clearance for the Cayetano stronghold. 17 hours ago DIZON DPWH TAGUIG OK Are you sure you want to log out? Yes No X Login Philstar.com is one of the most vibrant, opinionated, discerning communities of readers on cyberspace. With your meaningful insights, help shape the stories that can shape the country. Sign up now!
